|
|
|
|

Review Date: 11/14/2008
Welcome, Good Comic Reader, to
the official christening of a name for my little corner
of the comic review world. It's been suggested that
we need to add some identity to this little patch of opinion,
a naming of place so to speak. These reviews are subjective,
in that they're strictly my personal opinion, based on my
own comic world likes or dislikes. As such, they evolve
from my own comic experience, influenced by personal
memories stretching back over the years and decades of the
comics that I've been fortunate enough to read, enjoy and
love.
I want to reach back
as far as possible, to the very beginning, to the earliest
memory that I can clearly recall of a comic world of stories,
characters and wonder, and I'd like to bring that memory
back to the present, share it with you and honor it
by naming this review place after that first comic encounter.
This first memory of mine predates reading, even. Its
of an early 1960's Saturday morning cartoon show.
It was called Bongo Congo, and offered a world of talking
animals in this ficticious African country, including the
lion ruler Good King Leonardo, his advisor True Blue Odie
and a host of other characters.
You may ask why I chose a t.v.
cartoon show setting rather than a comic book world to name
this column. The answer is simple, in that I believe
that we baby boomers got hooked on comics mainly because
of Saturday morning cartoons. Think about it for a
moment: we watched and fell in love with t.v. cartoons as
toddlers, before we could even read. That interest
was naturally expanded to include the written word on the
graphic page as we first learned to read. Admit it
to yourself; there isn't a comic lover in the world who
didn't start as a Saturday morning cartoon person, and who
to this day doesn't carry on the intertwined traditions
of comics and t.v. cartoons. That's the reason why
adults nationwide have made The Simpsons the longest-running
half-hour sitcom, live or animated, in television history.
So come join me each week "Here
In Bongo Congo", Good Comic Reader. Perhaps Leonardo
and Odie will weigh-in from time-to-time with their own
opinions, or to help-out with the comic contest judging.
It's all in good fun, and we could all do worse than taking
a few moments each week to hang-out here in Bongo Congo.
Now on to this week's reviews!
 |
Terra
#1
Amanda Conner: penciler,
inker,
Jimmy Palmiotti: writer, inker,
Justin Gray: writer |
D.C.
has just released issue #1 of a four issue mini-series
entitled "Terra." The title character is a fairly
new, young DC Universe superheroine who first appeared
in Supergirl #12. As such, she's a completely
different character from a few previous Terra's
who have inhabited various DC comic lines since the
early 1980's.
This mini-series is written
by Justin Gray & Jimmy Palmiotti, with art by
Palmiotti and Amanda Conner. In issue #1, we're
introduced to the new Terra, a subterranean human
who uses her powers to manipulate the earth and
solid materials to rescue a group of trapped
Virginia coal miners. The comic writers are
adept at moving a lot more than the standard number
of story plot elements quickly forward, as a
series of Terra's rescue actions serve to
introduce her to an entire world of average
citizens as well as established superheros who
weren't previously aware of her existance.
We also learn a lot
about Terra's subterranean world inhabited by
exotic creatures, some intelligent and some not, who
are either allies or enemies of Terra and her referenced
species of underground humans. There's another
sub-plot woven-in of mining developers and government
agents intruding into this underground world.
Finally, toss Powergirl into this stew as
the established superhero character who has first
contact with this mysterious newcomer and you've got
quite a lot of storytelling crammed into the first
issue of this mini-series.
It would be easy to assume
from the above summary that there might be too many
plot elements going on in one standard-sized comic
to avoid confusion. But the creative team behind
this comic actually pulls it all off very well.
It's a well-crafted comic story, comfortably serving
the reader a mix of information on Terra's abilities,
the struggle between the surface world and her mysterious
underground land, and lots of interesting action and
story elements as she throws herself into saving folks
around the world from natural disasters.
The style of art in this
comic is a more critical element here than
in most comics that I've been reading of late.
Similar to Frank Cho's style in comics such as Liberty
Meadows and the current issue of Hulk #7 that I reviewed
last week, it's particularly effective in portraying
both the needed range of character's facial expressions
and the unique action required for Terra's specific
earth-moving superpowers.
All in all, I found this
comic to be very fresh and unique in both storyline
and artistic presentation. Definitely a thumbs-up
to check-out issue #1, and I for one will personally
stick around to see where this storyline goes for
the three following issues of this mini-series.
|
 |
Iron
Man-The End (Marvel One-Shot)
Cover By: Bob Layton
Writer: David Michelinie
Pencils: Bernard Chang
|
Marvel
has a new one-shot out this week entitled "Iron Man-The
End." This extra-length comic is written by
David Michelinie with art by Bernard Chang, Bob Layton
and Mike Cavallaro.
The premise of this story
is both original and intriguing. The unspecified time
is at least a few decades from now. Tony Stark has
been Iron Man for 50 years; after five decades of
armor clad battles, his battered body suffering from
a degenerative nerve disorder, Stark must face the
inevitability of giving-up the ghost and retiring
from being Iron Man.
Several concurrent major
plot elements receive equal focus in this
oversized comic issue, including Stark struggling
to accept his inability to perform as Iron Man, deciding
whether or not he should anoint a successor (I won't
give away the details of this plot line) and
his obsession through Stark Industries on
completing the world's first space elevator between
Earth and an orbiting geostationary space station.
Author Michelinie also portrays the inevitable stress
that these issues place on Stark's long-time marriage
to U.S. Senator Beth Cabe. As such, there's
a very heavy "Lion In Winter" theme to this comic,
as Stark deeply struggles to cope with this host
of last-stage-of-life issues.
I had to give this comic
a few days of thought between reading it and writing
this review, and came away from it all with mixed
feelings that lean toward the negative. I'm
bothered by the flat feeling to the story; while
its partly due to the bleak themes of the plotline,
its mainly because this really isn't a comic superhero
story. Instead, what we have here is a hard
technology science fiction short story portrayed in
graphic format. In fact, I am positive that
sometime back in the 1980's I read this exact plot
as a science fiction short story by either Arthur
C. Clarke, Larry Niven or a similar science fiction
writer of that era. That story had the exact same
story elements of a scientist struggling with
health issues later in life as he labored to complete the
first Earth-to-space station space elevator.
Even the ending of the story was the same as this
comic.
Since there's no statement
in the comic referencing the earlier short story,
I have to wonder if Marvel and the first story's author
are aware of this situation. However, that old
story/new comic connection isn't the problem with
this issue. The basic fact is that while this
particular hard science plot works in a short story
format, its dry and frankly forced in a
comic book format. There's little real emotion
of any sort, here, leaving the reader with a feeling
that something standard in a superhero comic is missing
that's essential to enjoying the read.
While I'm giving this comic a general
thumbs down, I'll make a qualified recommendation
that die-hard, long-time Iron Man fans might
still want to check it out and add it to their collection
inventory, as an interesting, albeit flawed, addition
to the long lineage and wide range of interpretations
of Iron Man over the years. As a die-hard Superman
and Batman collector/fan, I love to check-out as many
interpretive versions as possible of both D.C. heroes.
Flawed or not, each creative interpretation adds an
interesting depth and distinctive flavor to my favorite
heroe's comic book and popular culture legacies.
So if Iron Man is one of your top comic hero icons,
feel free to add this one-shot to your inventory.
If otherwise you're just looking for a fun read, with
all due respect to the creative team's effort, skip
this one.
|
-
CONTEST
REMINDER!
Just a reminder
that there's one more week to enter our current contest.
Give us your entry for your favorite individual comic issue
from the 1990's. It was a great decade for comics,
with such comic lines as Neil Gaiman's Sandman, Kurt Busiek's
Astro City, Concrete, From Hell and D.C.'s Kingdom Come,
just to name a few. Come on, you must have a favorite
issue from one of these lines, or from another 1990's series!
So e-mail me at Gordon_A@msn.com,
and tell me what individual issue of a comic published between
1990 and 1999 was your favorite comic issue of that decade,
and why. Good Luck!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|