|
|
|
|
Review
Date: 07/03/2008
|
Batman
#676 (the start of the Batman R.I.P. story arc series)
Mike Marts: Editor
Jeanine Schaefer: Editor
Alex Ross: Artist, Cover
Grant Morrison: Writer
Sandu Florea: Artist
Tony Daniel: Artist
Guy Major: Colorer
Randy Gentile: Letterer |
D.C.'s latest Batman multi-issue story
arc is entitled "Batman R.I.P.," consisting of 20 upcoming
issues to be published concurrently across five D.C.
titles: Batman 676-681, Detective 846-850, Nightwing
147-150, Robin 175-176 and Batman & The Outsiders
11-13. The R.I.P. series begins in Batman 676;
both issues 676 and 677 are currently available at That's
Entertainment. Issue 676 is written by Grant Morrison,
penciled by Tony Daniel and inked by Sandu Florea.
Having grown-up in the Silver
Age, I'm a fanatical Batman fan. He's basically
my favorite superhero, and I read issue #676, entitled
"Midnight In The House Of Hurt," hoping that maybe Morrison
had given us a worthy follow-up to the acclaimed Batman:
Hush story arc of a few years ago.
I guess we'll have to keep
waiting. Granted, it's the first issue of a 20-issue
story arc, and maybe these long-run arcs need some time
to establish a consistent plot and story details, but
something feels really wrong with the kick-off issue
for this series. The plot seems to be about Batman
trying to infiltrate The Black Glove supervillain crime
organization, as prominent Gothamites, including Bruce
Wayne, are being invited to an uppercrust party called
the "Danse Macabre," very publicly sponsored by The
Black Glove.
The problem with this kick-off
issue is four-fold. First, the storyline and dialogue
never consistently jell from page-to-page. Sub-plots
feel so random and frankly needless to the main storyline
(Robin having some identity angst as Batman's sidekick,
Bruce Wayne's latest eyecandy girlfriend trying to console
him over the long-time pain of his parent's death, etc.),
that it feels like the reader is dropped into the fourth
or fifth issue of a series without having read key previous
issues.
Secondly, those sub-plots.
Long-time Batman readers deserve something at least
a little fresh; re-hashing Robin's sidekick insecurities
and Bruce Wayne's orphan pain is hardly new to the Batman
world, and feels like Morrison is just mailing-in an
effort at a fresh script.
Third, naturally The Joker
weighs-in, on the final four pages of the issue,
via reference to a Joker parvovirus that causes the
infected to literally laugh their guts out. There's
a weird reference to "millions of people" across America having
already died from this Joker virus, and the issue
artists deliver a few panels of a t.v. newscaster succumbing
to the disease. I don't enjoy the trend during
the past decade of some D.C. artists trying to out-bloody
each other when it comes to Joker-related art.
Its just plain gross and pointless. Enough with
the buckets of blood, already.
Fourth and finally, I'm just
not a fan of the D.C. strategy of trying longer "mega-story
arcs." I was disappointed in "52" last year, and
feel that the D.C. longer story arc strategy should
be limited to 12 issue runs, a la Batman: Hush or the
currently-concluding All-Star Superman series.
Running 20 issues in five parallel comic titles is a
financial disservice to loyal fans budgeting their entertainment
money in tough economic times, and comes-off as
a short-term sales revenue strategy more than anything.
Does Marvel rely on this sales ploy? Please let me know
if D.C. is not alone in seeming to increasingly make use
of this money-making gimmick.
As such, unfortunately I have
to recommend that the happy D.C. reader take a pass
on this tired-feeling story series; to me, R.I.P. is
D.O.A. On a final note, please feel free to e-mail
me your thoguhts on this one at Gordon_A@msn.com,
particularly whether you agree or disagree on my reaction
toward the trend on mega-length story arcs and concurrent
comic title story runs. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|